From the kata description:

Rules for a smiling face:

• Each smiley face must contain a valid pair of eyes. Eyes can be marked as : or ;
• A smiley face can have a nose but it does not have to. Valid characters for a nose are - or ~
• Every smiling face must have a smiling mouth that should be marked with either ) or D

":-D" is a valid smiley that your solution doesn't count.